Compare the Best 5 Estate Agents in Thurlstone

List of Estate Agents in Thurlstone

1. 

   

   Lancasters Property Services - Penistone

   20 Market Street, Penistone, S36 6BZ

   

   (73 reviews)

   See agent performance

   

   30th Oct 2026 (2 days ago)

   Lancasters continue to disappoint me. They don't respond to emails, and give fake promises over the phone. I have been nothing but patient and polite. But it's beyond ridiculous how they have treated me with such disregard as a tenant.<br><br>I've made another report 6 months ago and absolutely has been done.<br>There are issues with damp and black mold, blocked plumbing, freezing draughts, leaking roof. (Most of which has actually been reported as far back as 2024.)<br><br>When I moved into the property they said it would be deep cleaned. It wasn’t. It took a full day of cleaning before moving our belongings because it was absolutely filthy.<br><br>After a few months I noticed many poorly done fixes to make the house appear rentable. Alot of things had just been left broken or unusable even though there was plenty of time for it to be fixed beforehand.<br><br>I'm extremely disappointed in Lancasters lack of service and professionalism.<br><br>Edit in response to Lancasters: Not even 3 days after this review was made my partner was contacted by the agent who is in charge of this property to ask if we had left the review. He asked me to remove his name from the review which I did, (through gritted teeth) but this was the only reason we were contacted and the only reason why any works took place. It took naming an agent and to actually get something done. (Even though that something hasn't been completely resolved.)<br><br>It took over a month for the repointing to be done to the house and for extractor fans to be put in the kitchen and bathroom (which somehow don't help)<br>The house is still freezing, the roof is still leaking when it rains and the toilet is still backed up. As of October 2026 it's now been EIGHT MONTHS since I've reported the leak and the plumbing. I contacted your "unnamed agent" again last week asking for an update and was fobbed off. Again.<br><br>So we're back to square one.<br><br>Also to try and gaslight your tenants by saying the review isn't verified because I'm not using the name on my birth certificate as a username is ridiculous to say the least. I feel like ripping my hair out every time I have to attempt contact with Lancasters to be met with dismissive responses.... Read more

   See agent performance
2. 

   

   Simon Blyth Estate Agents - Penistone

   1a St Marys Street, Penistone, S36 6DT

   

   (110 reviews)

   See agent performance

   

   9th Oct 2026 (23 days ago)

   Maria and Maddison were amazing in our house sale and purchase. Things weren’t so straightforward but they ensured we had regular updates and made sure our house sale and purchase was completed. Maria even went over and above and drove documents to Sheffield to ensure we exchanged on the right day. Thanks so much - we love our new home! ??????... Read more

   See agent performance
3. 

   

   Butcher Residential - Penistone

   2 Crown House Shrewsbury Road, Penistone, S36 3DY

   

   (9 reviews)

   See agent performance

   

   18th Sep 2026 (6 weeks ago)

   Mostly a positive experience, though felt like it could have been smoother - particularly as it was a no chain property with a buyer who didn’t have anywhere to sell, but it still took the best part of six months. The tenant also was buying a property advertised by the agent, but communication was poor between the people at Butchers, so they did not coordinate.... Read more

   See agent performance
4. 

   

   The Pennine Property Group

   12 St. Marys Street Penistone, S36 6DT

   

   (65 reviews)

   See agent performance

   

   21st Oct 2026 (11 days ago)

   I sold my house with Pennine Properties this year, and they were fantastic from start to finish! Lizzie was amazing throughout the whole process, always offering great advice and keeping me informed every step of the way.<br><br>I can’t thank Lizzie and the team at Pennine Properties enough for all their help and support in making the whole process run so smoothly. I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend them to anyone looking to sell their property. Highly recommend!... Read more

   See agent performance
5. 

   

   Mallinson and Co - Penistone

   Suite 2, Penistone 1, St. Marys Street,Penistone, S36 6DT

   

   (171 reviews)

   See agent performance

   

   19th Oct 2026 (13 days ago)

   Found a property through this agent and they were very helpful with great communication, Mike who showed us around a couple of properties was very informative with no pushy sales techniques, looking forward to moving into our new found house!... Read more

   See agent performance

FAQs