5 Estate Agents in Thurlstone

List of Estate Agents in Thurlstone

1. 

   

   Lancasters Property Services - Penistone

   20 Market Street, Penistone, S36 6BZ

   

   (73 reviews)

   See agent performance

   

   9th Sep 2026 (8 days ago)

   1 star — Avoid if you want a letting agent that communicates and takes responsibility<br><br>Don’t leave a review until you have experienced their services as a tenant!<br><br>My experience with this letting agent has been exceptionally poor, and I would not recommend them.<br><br>The biggest issue has been the way problems are handled once something goes wrong. In my experience, communication has been unreliable, commitments have not been followed through, and I have repeatedly been left having to chase matters that should have been dealt with by the agent.<br><br>My dealings with Daniel White have been particularly disappointing. Meetings have been arranged and then not attended. I have been given assurances that were not followed through, and I have had to challenge information that I believe was inaccurate. The result is that I have had very little confidence in anything I have been told.<br><br>The agent has also handled harassment I have experienced within the building poorly. I have raised concerns about the behaviour I have been subjected to, but I have not felt that these concerns were taken seriously or dealt with appropriately. Rather than receiving clear communication, meaningful support or evidence of proactive action, I have been left feeling isolated and responsible for repeatedly chasing the matter myself.<br><br>A letting agent should take complaints about harassment seriously, respond promptly, keep tenants informed and take reasonable steps to address concerns—particularly where the behaviour affects a tenant’s safety, wellbeing or ability to live peacefully in their home. In my experience, that standard has not been met.<br><br>Most concerning has been the handling of essential maintenance. My boiler has been known to have serious problems for months. Their engineer has attended on multiple occasions attempting to fit parts, despite indicating that the boiler is too old to be realistically repaired. I have now been left without hot water for an extended period, yet the agent has still failed to take appropriate action.<br><br>This is not a minor inconvenience. Hot water is a basic necessity, and a letting agent should take an urgent and proactive approach when an essential service fails. Instead, I have experienced delays, excuses, missed meetings and repeated chasing.<br><br>What has been most frustrating is that I have made every effort to deal with these issues reasonably and through the proper channels. Unfortunately, the impression left is that problems are simply allowed to drag on until the tenant becomes exhausted from pursuing them.<br><br>A letting agent should provide professionalism, honesty, communication and accountability. Sadly, I have experienced very little of any of these.<br><br>If you are considering renting a property through this agent, I would strongly suggest you look very carefully at how they deal with existing tenants before committing yourself. Getting the keys is one thing; getting problems resolved afterwards is another.<br><br>Based entirely on my own experience, I would not use this letting agent again and I would not recommend them to prospective tenants.... Read more

   See agent performance
2. 

   

   Simon Blyth Estate Agents - Penistone

   1a St Marys Street, Penistone, S36 6DT

   

   (105 reviews)

   See agent performance

   

   15th Apr 2026 (22 weeks ago)

   I cannot recommend Simon Blyth’s Penistone office highly enough! As a first-time buyer, they guided me through every single step of the process. They were proactive in communication, always replying quickly to my calls and emails. What could have been a stressful experience turned into exciting and smooth process.... Read more

   See agent performance
3. 

   

   Butcher Residential - Penistone

   2 Crown House Shrewsbury Road, Penistone, S36 3DY

   

   (8 reviews)

   See agent performance

   

   26th Jun 2026 (12 weeks ago)

   A very quick sale so can’t complain at all... Read more

   See agent performance
4. 

   

   The Pennine Property Group

   12 St. Marys Street Penistone, S36 6DT

   

   (62 reviews)

   See agent performance

   

   28th Jul 2026 (7 weeks ago)

   ?????<br><br>Lizzie at Pennine Property was absolutely fantastic throughout the sale of our home and the purchase of our new one. From day one, her communication was outstanding—she kept us informed at every stage, was always friendly, professional and incredibly personable.<br><br>She worked tirelessly to keep everything progressing, regularly chasing solicitors and ensuring the process moved forward as efficiently as possible. Her dedication and proactive approach gave us real confidence throughout what can often be a stressful experience.<br><br>The level of customer service we received from Lizzie and the team at Pennine Property was exceptional, and we wouldn’t hesitate to recommend them to anyone looking to buy or sell a home.<br><br>A huge thank you for all your hard work and support—we truly appreciate everything you’ve done for us.<br><br>Richard & Jade... Read more

   See agent performance
5. 

   

   Mallinson and Co - Penistone

   Suite 2, Penistone 1, St. Marys Street,Penistone, S36 6DT

   

   (169 reviews)

   See agent performance

   

   5th Aug 2026 (6 weeks ago)

   I can't recommend Jake at Mallinson & Co highly enough. From the very beginning, he has been incredibly efficient, professional and genuinely helpful throughout my purchase journey so far.<br><br>Jake submitted my very first offer on what will be my dream home, and he has gone above and beyond at every stage since. He even delayed his lunch break so I could get to the office with my paperwork, then helped with all the technical side of uploading the documents so everything could be processed quickly.<br><br>Communication has been outstanding. Jake has kept me fully informed about my vendor's house search and the progress of the rest of the chain, so I've always known where things stood. He also instructed my solicitors on my behalf, making the whole process much smoother and taking a lot of the stress away.<br><br>Whenever I've called or emailed, Jake has always responded promptly.<br><br>If you're buying or selling a property, I wouldn't hesitate to recommend Jake and the team at Mallinson & Co. A first-class service from start to hopefully the end of my purchase of my dream home - 10/10!... Read more

   See agent performance

FAQs