Back
Close
  • Compare agents
  • Online valuation
  • Explore my area
  • Home toolkit
  • News & guides
Sign In To Agent Shortlist
Agent Shortlist
Sign In To HouseWorth
HouseWorth
  • Estate agents by area
  • Sold house prices by area
Search by Location or Name
  • Selling guides
  • Estate agent guides
  • Mortgage advice
  • Conveyancing guides
  • Property news
  • See All News & Guides
Sign in
Sign In To Agent Shortlist

Agent shortlist

Sign In To HouseWorth

HouseWorth

© GetAgent Limited 2026
  1. Estate Agents in Barnsley and surrounding villages

Compare the Best 48 Estate Agents in Barnsley and surrounding villages

See Fees, Sale Times and Reviews for Barnsley and surrounding villages Estate Agents

Looking for the best estate agents in Barnsley and surrounding villages? In the last 6 months, 3,177 properties have been listed for sale, and the average asking price in Barnsley and surrounding villages is £220,107. Homes typically take 10 weeks to go under offer. Fees from participating agents active locally average 1.35% including VAT, with a typical range of 1.2%–1.62%. These fees are evaluated at the area’s average listing value of £229,005 and weighted by sales-listing activity over the past six months. They are estimates, not individual quotes.

Barnsley and surrounding villages Property Market Summary
  • Average asking price£220,107
  • Average sale time10 weeks
  • Asking price change-2.1%
  • Average estate agent fee incl. VAT1.35%

Based on 49 participating agents at an average area listing value of £229,005. Calculated 2026-11-06.

See the fee calculator and methodology
See the full breakdown of .

Find out how much your property is worth

Get an instant online valuation in just a few seconds!
Get started

List of Estate Agents in Barnsley and surrounding villages

Showing 1 - 25 of 48
  1. Hunters - Barnsley Logo

    Hunters - Barnsley

    1-3 Church Street, Barnsley, South Yorkshire, S70 2AB
    Average 4.8/5 Stars

    (248 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    21st Oct 2026 (16 days ago)
    After an unexpected bereavement, Zack and his team expertly navigated us through the selling of the bungalow.

    We found the team to be extremely professional, and personal - always going above and beyond when it came to dealing with other third party companies and communicating with the buyer.

    There aren’t adequate words to describe how grateful we are for how Zach and the team helped us as we journeyed through the ups and downs at this sale. We can’t recommend them enough!
    ... Read more
  2. Lancasters Property Services - Penistone Logo

    Lancasters Property Services - Penistone

    20 Market Street, Penistone, S36 6BZ
    Average 4.1/5 Stars

    (73 reviews)

    Average 1/5 Stars
    30th Oct 2026 (7 days ago)
    Lancasters continue to disappoint me. They don't respond to emails, and give fake promises over the phone. I have been nothing but patient and polite. But it's beyond ridiculous how they have treated me with such disregard as a tenant.

    I've made another report 6 months ago and absolutely has been done.
    There are issues with damp and black mold, blocked plumbing, freezing draughts, leaking roof. (Most of which has actually been reported as far back as 2024.)

    When I moved into the property they said it would be deep cleaned. It wasn’t. It took a full day of cleaning before moving our belongings because it was absolutely filthy.

    After a few months I noticed many poorly done fixes to make the house appear rentable. Alot of things had just been left broken or unusable even though there was plenty of time for it to be fixed beforehand.

    I'm extremely disappointed in Lancasters lack of service and professionalism.

    Edit in response to Lancasters: Not even 3 days after this review was made my partner was contacted by the agent who is in charge of this property to ask if we had left the review. He asked me to remove his name from the review which I did, (through gritted teeth) but this was the only reason we were contacted and the only reason why any works took place. It took naming an agent and to actually get something done. (Even though that something hasn't been completely resolved.)

    It took over a month for the repointing to be done to the house and for extractor fans to be put in the kitchen and bathroom (which somehow don't help)
    The house is still freezing, the roof is still leaking when it rains and the toilet is still backed up. As of October 2026 it's now been EIGHT MONTHS since I've reported the leak and the plumbing. I contacted your "unnamed agent" again last week asking for an update and was fobbed off. Again.

    So we're back to square one.

    Also to try and gaslight your tenants by saying the review isn't verified because I'm not using the name on my birth certificate as a username is ridiculous to say the least. I feel like ripping my hair out every time I have to attempt contact with Lancasters to be met with dismissive responses.
    ... Read more
  3. Simon Blyth Estate Agents - Penistone Logo

    Simon Blyth Estate Agents - Penistone

    1a St Marys Street, Penistone, S36 6DT
    Average 4.8/5 Stars

    (110 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    9th Oct 2026 (28 days ago)
    Maria and Maddison were amazing in our house sale and purchase. Things weren’t so straightforward but they ensured we had regular updates and made sure our house sale and purchase was completed. Maria even went over and above and drove documents to Sheffield to ensure we exchanged on the right day. Thanks so much - we love our new home! ??????... Read more
  4. Wilbys - Barnsley Logo

    Wilbys - Barnsley

    6A Eastgate, Barnsley, S70 2EP
    Average 5.0/5 Stars

    (6 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    19th Sep 2026 (7 weeks ago)
    Wilby’s are an excellent estate agent. Nothing was too trouble for them. They sold my house within two days of it being on the market. I highly recommend them. Lovely people.... Read more
  5. William H Brown - Barnsley Logo

    William H Brown - Barnsley

    24 Market Hill, S70 2QE
    Average 4.2/5 Stars

    (350 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    27th Oct 2026 (10 days ago)
    WH Brown manage our rental property for us and we couldn’t be happier with the level of support we receive from the letting and property management team.
    Erica Collins has been outstanding. Also, to mention Scarlett Rafferty who has also been outstanding. Nothing is too much trouble and communication is excellent.
    We are more than happy with the service they provide.
    ... Read more
  6. Gates Estates - Barnsley Head Office Logo

    Gates Estates - Barnsley Head Office

    196 Sheffield Road Birdwell Barnsley, S70 5TD
    Average 4.5/5 Stars

    (175 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    21st Oct 2026 (16 days ago)
    Great staff, very friendly and helpful.... Read more
  7. Your Move - Barnsley Logo

    Your Move - Barnsley

    Eldon Street, S70 2JR
    Average 4.6/5 Stars

    (232 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    2nd Oct 2026 (5 weeks ago)
    Charlotte Hinds has been an absolute pleasure to have on my case, and throughout the process with the sellers solicitor and my solicitor, has been the only one who seems to consistently have their ducks in a row. So organised and willing to go one step further for everyone.... Read more
  8. Your Move - Furness Lyman Logo

    Your Move - Furness Lyman

    64 High Street, Wombwell, S73 8DA
    Average 4.9/5 Stars

    (11 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    5th Nov 2026 (1 day ago)
    I felt comfortable and confident with Matthew from day one. My house has only been on the market 3 weeks and with all their help I have accepted one of two offers received. Very happy... Read more
  9. Trigglets Ltd Logo

    Trigglets Ltd

    Unit 60 Century Business Centre, Manvers, S63 5DA
    Average 4.4/5 Stars

    (34 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    13th Jun 2024 (2 years ago)
    Very helpful local estate agent . All the staff very good... Read more
  10. The Pennine Property Group Logo

    The Pennine Property Group

    12 St. Marys Street Penistone, S36 6DT
    Average 4.9/5 Stars

    (65 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    21st Oct 2026 (16 days ago)
    I sold my house with Pennine Properties this year, and they were fantastic from start to finish! Lizzie was amazing throughout the whole process, always offering great advice and keeping me informed every step of the way.

    I can’t thank Lizzie and the team at Pennine Properties enough for all their help and support in making the whole process run so smoothly. I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend them to anyone looking to sell their property. Highly recommend!
    ... Read more
  11. Haybrook - Barnsley Logo

    Haybrook - Barnsley

    1 Market Hill, Barnsley, S70 2PS
    Average 4.4/5 Stars

    (8 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    14th Jun 2025 (1 year ago)
    So far everything has been very good , no problems . All members of staff have been very informative , pleasant and polite . I would recommend Haybrooks , my house is SSC after only 7 weeks .... Read more
  12. Beecroft Estates - Barnsley Logo

    Beecroft Estates - Barnsley

    6-8 Park Street Wombwell, Barnsley, S73 0DJ
    Average 4.3/5 Stars

    (387 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    31st Oct 2026 (6 days ago)
    We had a fantastic experience with Millie C when finding and securing our first rental property together. From start to finish she was incredibly helpful, friendly and professional, making what could have been a stressful process feel so much easier.

    She was always approachable, quick to respond to any questions we had and kept us informed throughout the whole process. As first-time renters, we really appreciated her support, patience and guidance, which made us feel comfortable and confident every step of the process

    We honestly couldn’t have asked for a better experience and are so grateful for all her help in getting us into our first home together! Thank you, Millie! We would highly recommend her and Beecroft Estates!
    ... Read more
  13. Whitegates - Barnsley Logo

    Whitegates - Barnsley

    17/19 Church Street, Barnsley, South Yorkshire, S70 2AB
    Average 4.7/5 Stars

    (95 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    28th Aug 2025 (1 year ago)
    It wasn’t a straightforward sale but Whitegates were exceptionally good throughout. Communications at all times were excellent. Thanks Will, Steve, Luke and Sarah. With apologies to Spinal Tap, 11 out of 10. Thoroughly reccomended. Keith Fisher, Paraguay.... Read more
  14. Simon Blyth Estate Agents - Barnsley Logo

    Simon Blyth Estate Agents - Barnsley

    16 Regent Street, Barnsley, S70 2HG
    Average 4.7/5 Stars

    (49 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    20th Sep 2025 (1 year ago)
    We feel they have made the process of selling our son’s property so much easier for us. They have a friendly, honest approach and have keep communication going at all times, which has been extremely helpful for us.... Read more
  15. Armitage Residential - Barnsley Logo

    Armitage Residential - Barnsley

    The Business Village, Innovation Way, Barnsley, S75 1JL
    Average 4.8/5 Stars

    (45 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    9th May 2026 (5 mo. ago)
    We’ve had such a positive experience with our letting agency from start to finish. The whole team has been professional, friendly, and always quick to help with anything we’ve needed. A special mention has to go to Debbie, who has been absolutely wonderful throughout. She is warm, approachable, and genuinely cares about making everything as smooth and stress-free as possible. Nothing is ever too much trouble for her, and her kindness and professionalism really stand out. We truly appreciate all of Debbie’s help and would highly recommend this letting agency to anyone looking for excellent service. - Michaela&jodie... Read more
  16. G8 Property - Rotherham Logo

    G8 Property - Rotherham

    40-42 Sheffield Road, Barnsley, S70 1HP
    Average 4.6/5 Stars

    (146 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    12th Oct 2026 (25 days ago)
    Nice, professional people. Evaluated the wishes and found the desired option.... Read more
  17. Hunters - Rotherham North Logo

    Hunters - Rotherham North

    49 High Street, Bolton Upon Dearne, Rotherham, S63 8LH
    Average 4.6/5 Stars

    (18 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    26th Aug 2025 (1 year ago)
    Great, friendly, helpful, and professional... Read more
  18. Butcher Residential - Denby Dale Logo

    Butcher Residential - Denby Dale

    361 Wakefield Road, Denby Dale, Huddersfield, HD8 8RP
    Average 5.0/5 Stars

    (63 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    26th Oct 2026 (11 days ago)
    Lovely staff, most of the time I spoke with Mel who was really friendly and helpful, I only purchased with butchers but due to my positive experience I would actually use them when it comes to selling my own property next time. Thanks!... Read more
  19. NestledIn - Barnsley Logo

    NestledIn - Barnsley

    The Business Village @Barnsley BIC, Barnsley, S75 1JL
    Average 4.9/5 Stars

    (55 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    18th Sep 2026 (7 weeks ago)
    Easy process,kept up to date throughout.... Read more
  20. Roebucks Estate Agents - Barnsley Logo

    Roebucks Estate Agents - Barnsley

    Digital Media Centre County Way,Barnsley, S70 2JW
    Average 3.7/5 Stars

    (3 reviews)

    Average 1/5 Stars
    15th Mar 2024 (2 years ago)
    Initially good to deal with. Purchased a new home through them and found them pleasant. However, things have gone downhill after we found that the new home we purchased was not mortgageable. Have told us that they have nothing to do with the deposit we paid even though they sent the e-mail with bank details on. Would not recommend as at the first sign of a problem they have disappeared and washed their hands of us.... Read more
  21. Paisley Properties - Mapplewell Logo

    Paisley Properties - Mapplewell

    4 Blacker Road,Mapplewell,Barnsley, S75 6BW
    Average 4.9/5 Stars

    (76 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    14th Oct 2026 (23 days ago)
    We recently instructed Paisleys to deal with the sale of our property and the property we purchased was also dealt with by Paisleys. Amber, Hannah and the whole team were excellent throughout the process, they kept us fully informed and their communication was excellent. If we sell another property we will absolutely use Paisleys again and would not hesitate to recommend them to anyone (they are also very reasonably priced.)... Read more
  22. Mallinson and Co - Penistone Logo

    Mallinson and Co - Penistone

    Suite 2, Penistone 1, St. Marys Street,Penistone, S36 6DT
    Average 4.8/5 Stars

    (176 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    4th Nov 2026 (2 days ago)
    Mallinson’s team were incredibly helpful throughout the process. They were easy to get hold of and prompt with any queries we had. The video of the house and marketing was brilliant! Would 100% recommend them to anyone looking to buy or sell a property.... Read more
  23. Sanders Estates - Barnsley Logo

    Sanders Estates - Barnsley

    57 pine hall drive, molnk bretton, barnsley, s71 2ns
    Average 5.0/5 Stars

    (13 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    4th Jul 2026 (18 weeks ago)
    I can't recommend Suzanne at Sanders Estates highly enough. From start to finish, she was absolutely amazing. She kept me informed throughout the whole process, was always professional, friendly, and happy to help with any questions I had.

    Buying a house can be stressful, but Suzanne made everything as smooth as possible with her excellent communication and support. Nothing ever seemed too much trouble, and I always felt like I was in safe hands.

    If I were selling a house in the future, I wouldn't hesitate to use Sanders Estates, and Suzanne would be my first choice.

    Thank you for all your hard work—I really appreciate everything you did to help me buy my new home.
    ... Read more
  24. JPM Estate Agents Logo

    JPM Estate Agents

    192 Green Road, Penistone, Sheffield, S36 6BG
    Average 5.0/5 Stars

    (82 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    25th Sep 2026 (6 weeks ago)
    Really helpful and quick responses. Very happy with the service provided by the team at JPM Estate Agents. Would recommend.... Read more
  25. William H Brown - Barnsley Logo

    William H Brown - Barnsley

    24 Market Hill, Barnsley, S70 2QE
    Average null/5 Stars
1
2

Looking to buy in Barnsley and surrounding villages?

Discover off-market homes in Barnsley and surrounding villages before they reach the major property portals.

Browse off-market homes in Barnsley and surrounding villages

Agents in this area will typically be able to sell your house in Athersley South, Barnsley, Barugh, Central Barnsley, Dodworth, Mapplewell, Monk Bretton and Stainborough. If you're looking for an estate agent in Wentworth Castle, Wilthorpe, Worsbrough and Worsbrough Dale and other local areas, the majority of these agents will also be able to help you sell your house too.

Choosing the right estate agent in Barnsley and surrounding villages matters more than most sellers realise. With 157 agents currently active across the area, performance varies considerably - some agents keep price changes to a minimum while others regularly make larger reductions. GetAgent pulls together verified sales data for every agent listed here so you can compare them on what actually counts: how quickly they sell, how much they typically reduce asking prices by, and what previous sellers say about working with them.

How to Compare Estate Agents in Barnsley and surrounding villages

1

Find Local Agents

Enter your Barnsley and surrounding villages postcode to see local agents ranked by performance.

2

Compare Their Performance

Compare fees, average sale time and percentage of asking price achieved in Barnsley and surrounding villages.

3

Book Free Valuations

Book free, no-obligation valuations with the agents that fit, and choose the right one for your sale.

FAQs

Explore agents near Barnsley and surrounding villages

Are you thinking of selling?

Our friendly team of experts are here to guide you through the process of selling your property. Give us a ring for some free advice on how to choose the right agent for you.
  • 020 3608 6556
  • Our lines are closed
Excellent
10,038 reviews onTrustpilot

Compare all Estate Agents in Barnsley and surrounding villages

Compare agent performance and fees, and find the best one to sell your home.
  • Data-driven recommendations
  • No obligation
  • Fast & easy

Compare all Estate Agents in Barnsley and surrounding villages

Compare agent performance and fees, and find the best one to sell your home.
  • Data-driven recommendations
  • No obligation
  • Fast & easy

Get a property valuation

Get your FREE, personalised valuation report now!

  • Historical price changes and trends
  • Area demand analysis
  • List of best performing local agents
Property Value Report

Related posts

Estate agent leads a family around a potential new home.
Estate agent leads a family around a potential new home.

Estate Agents

What do estate agents do?

For each home sale there are several steps estate agents have to follow, and a minefield of legal requirements they have to comply with.…

Read more

The Estate Agent comparison site
GetAgent LinkedIn iconGetAgent Facebook iconGetAgent X icon

Get in touch

020 3608 6556

Our lines are closed


We are a company registered in England & Wales, company number 09428979.

Copyright © 2026 GetAgent Limited