Back
Close
  • Compare agents
  • Online valuation
  • Explore my area
  • Home toolkit
  • News & guides
Sign In To Agent Shortlist
Agent Shortlist
Sign In To HouseWorth
HouseWorth
  • Estate agents by area
  • Sold house prices by area
Search by Location or Name
  • Selling guides
  • Estate agent guides
  • Mortgage advice
  • Conveyancing guides
  • Property news
  • See All News & Guides
Sign in
Sign In To Agent Shortlist

Agent shortlist

Sign In To HouseWorth

HouseWorth

© GetAgent Limited 2026
  1. Estate Agents in S35

78 Estate Agents in S35

Compare the performance of local estate agents.

Looking to compare estate agents in S35? In the last 6 months, 490 properties have been listed for sale by 78 different agents across the area. The average asking price in S35 is £276,109 and homes typically take 9 weeks to go under offer. Local agents charge an average fee of 1.1%, equating to around £3,032 on a typical sale.

S35 Property Market Summary
  • Average asking price£276,109
  • Average sale time9 weeks
  • Asking price change-2.2%
  • Average estate agent fee1.1%
See the full breakdown of .

Find out how much your property is worth

Get an instant online valuation in just a few seconds!
Get started

List of Estate Agents in S35

Showing 1 - 25 of 78
  1. Hunters - Barnsley Logo

    Hunters - Barnsley

    1-3 Church Street, Barnsley, South Yorkshire, S70 2AB
    Average 4.8/5 Stars

    (247 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    8th Oct 2026 (24 days ago)
    I have dealt with Robert at Hunters for the last few years, They do a great job looking after my rental properties and have always been professional, helpful and reliable. Would definitely recommend them.... Read more
  2. Big Red House Logo

    Big Red House

    The Castle Mill, Minneymoor Hill, Conisbrough, DN12 3EN
    Average 4.4/5 Stars

    (78 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    22nd Oct 2026 (10 days ago)
    Finally completed on a difficult property sale. Brh were great, especially Alison who helped me a great deal.... Read more
  3. Lancasters Property Services - Penistone Logo

    Lancasters Property Services - Penistone

    20 Market Street, Penistone, S36 6BZ
    Average 4.1/5 Stars

    (73 reviews)

    Average 1/5 Stars
    30th Oct 2026 (2 days ago)
    Lancasters continue to disappoint me. They don't respond to emails, and give fake promises over the phone. I have been nothing but patient and polite. But it's beyond ridiculous how they have treated me with such disregard as a tenant.<br><br>I've made another report 6 months ago and absolutely has been done.<br>There are issues with damp and black mold, blocked plumbing, freezing draughts, leaking roof. (Most of which has actually been reported as far back as 2024.)<br><br>When I moved into the property they said it would be deep cleaned. It wasn’t. It took a full day of cleaning before moving our belongings because it was absolutely filthy.<br><br>After a few months I noticed many poorly done fixes to make the house appear rentable. Alot of things had just been left broken or unusable even though there was plenty of time for it to be fixed beforehand.<br><br>I'm extremely disappointed in Lancasters lack of service and professionalism.<br><br>Edit in response to Lancasters: Not even 3 days after this review was made my partner was contacted by the agent who is in charge of this property to ask if we had left the review. He asked me to remove his name from the review which I did, (through gritted teeth) but this was the only reason we were contacted and the only reason why any works took place. It took naming an agent and to actually get something done. (Even though that something hasn't been completely resolved.)<br><br>It took over a month for the repointing to be done to the house and for extractor fans to be put in the kitchen and bathroom (which somehow don't help)<br>The house is still freezing, the roof is still leaking when it rains and the toilet is still backed up. As of October 2026 it's now been EIGHT MONTHS since I've reported the leak and the plumbing. I contacted your "unnamed agent" again last week asking for an update and was fobbed off. Again.<br><br>So we're back to square one.<br><br>Also to try and gaslight your tenants by saying the review isn't verified because I'm not using the name on my birth certificate as a username is ridiculous to say the least. I feel like ripping my hair out every time I have to attempt contact with Lancasters to be met with dismissive responses.... Read more
  4. Belvoir - Sheffield Logo

    Belvoir - Sheffield

    34 Campo Ln, Sheffield City Centre, Sheffield , S1 2EG
    Average 4.7/5 Stars

    (763 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    28th Sep 2026 (5 weeks ago)
    Belvoir helped me achieve a goal of renting my first property. Dawn Linfoot, who is the property manager of the residence I am staying in, has been a delight. She has consistently gone out of her way to help me out. Definitely couldn't have had a better first renting experience.... Read more
  5. Simon Blyth Estate Agents - Penistone Logo

    Simon Blyth Estate Agents - Penistone

    1a St Marys Street, Penistone, S36 6DT
    Average 4.8/5 Stars

    (110 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    9th Oct 2026 (23 days ago)
    Maria and Maddison were amazing in our house sale and purchase. Things weren’t so straightforward but they ensured we had regular updates and made sure our house sale and purchase was completed. Maria even went over and above and drove documents to Sheffield to ensure we exchanged on the right day. Thanks so much - we love our new home! ??????... Read more
  6. Blundells - Hillsborough Logo

    Blundells - Hillsborough

    41 Middlewood Road, S6 4GW
    Average 4.7/5 Stars

    (405 reviews)

    Average 1/5 Stars
    14th Oct 2026 (18 days ago)
    This service appears to screen calls and redirect unwanted numbers directly to voicemail. As a result, it is almost impossible to reach a real person. Very frustrating and unprofessional customer experience. I would not recommend them.... Read more
  7. William H Brown - Barnsley Logo

    William H Brown - Barnsley

    24 Market Hill, S70 2QE
    Average 4.2/5 Stars

    (350 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    27th Oct 2026 (5 days ago)
    WH Brown manage our rental property for us and we couldn’t be happier with the level of support we receive from the letting and property management team.<br>Erica Collins has been outstanding. Also, to mention Scarlett Rafferty who has also been outstanding. Nothing is too much trouble and communication is excellent.<br>We are more than happy with the service they provide.... Read more
  8. Reeds Rains - Hillsborough Logo

    Reeds Rains - Hillsborough

    39 Middlewood Road, S6 4GW
    Average 4.8/5 Stars

    (337 reviews)

    Average 1/5 Stars
    26th Oct 2026 (6 days ago)
    I sold a rental property with Gemma Bellamy's team in Jul 25, with Reeds selected after meeting Victoria, who was pretty much the only useful person I dealt with, but sparingly available.<br><br>Key issues:<br>- Negotiation was shockingly bad. Their approach was the standard "open house - here's your best offer" after 1 day of viewings. Little interest in negotiation/doing further viewings after. A somewhat satisfactory offer was only obtained further down the line when they were pushed into a corner to do this or lose the business.<br>- Poor progression skills. Maisie: amazingly bad at just about anything she touched. Cheryl: excellent at appeasing and then doing nothing of consequence after.<br>- Work is outsourced; this is used as an explanation as to why branch staff are clueless about your case<br>- Expensive for the quality of service. Another rental completed in half the time and at a competitive price by Hunters<br>- There was an entire day when no one was around to pick up the phone due to staff shortages<br>- The ability to successfully navigate curveballs associated with buyers in the area was a key concern discussed pre-selection and confirmed as a skillset. There was no apparent interest in tackling these when they arose.<br><br>In summary, a very substandard team overseen by a very substandard branch manager. I believe any other Hillsborough estate agent would do a better job of selling a house and at a lower cost.<br><br>EDIT: These concerns were raised repeatedly over the phone and e-mail. The fact that Josh is a lettings employee commenting on the performance of a sales team he doesn't belong to is an excellent example of how poor the sales team is at their job. I've attached some screenshots from just the tail end of a 5 month dragged out process seeing as "you have no record of these concerns". Loads more where that came from.<br><br>In further updates this morning, Josh claims that the team is human and has to start somewhere and that they've all magically improved to market leading standard over the last year. So if you'd like to wager the proceeds of your house sale on Josh's charity cases, look no further than Reeds Rains Hillsborough.... Read more
  9. Gates Estates - Barnsley Head Office Logo

    Gates Estates - Barnsley Head Office

    196 Sheffield Road Birdwell Barnsley, S70 5TD
    Average 4.5/5 Stars

    (175 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    21st Oct 2026 (11 days ago)
    Great staff, very friendly and helpful.... Read more
  10. Your Move - Chapeltown Logo

    Your Move - Chapeltown

    5 Market Street, Chapeltown, S35 2UW
    Average 4.7/5 Stars

    (186 reviews)

    Average 4/5 Stars
    23rd Oct 2026 (9 days ago)
    Great service from start to finish ?????? Always available to help and advice through our process... Read more
  11. Blundells - Chapeltown Logo

    Blundells - Chapeltown

    Unit 4 Market Street, Chapeltown, S35 2UW
    Average 4.7/5 Stars

    (137 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    7th Oct 2026 (25 days ago)
    Akos from Blundells has been wonderful to work with throughout my house purchase, making sure everything stays on track! I would recommend Blundells due to my experience throughout this process.... Read more
  12. Martin & Co - Rotherham Logo

    Martin & Co - Rotherham

    5 Worry Goose Lane, Whiston, S60 4AA
    Average 4.7/5 Stars

    (97 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    22nd Oct 2026 (10 days ago)
    I have never known a company as efficient as yourselves. The communication is second to none. Paul's been absolutely fantastic. I was really worried and apprehensive about selling my childhood home.<br>The journey has been seamless with the help of Paul.<br>I can't believe how professional and supportive Sue and Paul have been throughout the process.<br>What I thought would be a daunting task selling my Mums property after her passing couldn't have been any simpler.<br>I would have no hesitation at all recommending this company to anyone.<br>Thank you from the bottom of my heart.... Read more
  13. William H Brown - Rotherham Logo

    William H Brown - Rotherham

    32 Mansfield Road, S60 2DR
    Average 4.4/5 Stars

    (301 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    27th Oct 2026 (5 days ago)
    I had my property on the market for almost 9 months with another agent and struggled to find tenants, so i decided on a whim to try out William H Brown and I was in for a pleasant surprise to say the least. Within a week of having the property on the market, I found a tenant.<br><br>The process was smooth and I was kept well informed all through. The service was A-star, and I am beyond pleased with the outcome.<br><br>Thank you to the whole team for providing much needed support and advice at a very difficult time. To Jack from sales, thank you for initially taking my enquiry and running with it. I would especially like to recognise and appreciate Jasmine from lettings for her professionalism, knowledge of the market, attention to detail and speedy response to resolve potential issues.<br><br>Thank you, William H Brown, Rotherham.<br><br>You have made me very happy.... Read more
  14. The Pennine Property Group Logo

    The Pennine Property Group

    12 St. Marys Street Penistone, S36 6DT
    Average 4.9/5 Stars

    (65 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    21st Oct 2026 (11 days ago)
    I sold my house with Pennine Properties this year, and they were fantastic from start to finish! Lizzie was amazing throughout the whole process, always offering great advice and keeping me informed every step of the way.<br><br>I can’t thank Lizzie and the team at Pennine Properties enough for all their help and support in making the whole process run so smoothly. I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend them to anyone looking to sell their property. Highly recommend!... Read more
  15. Redbrik - Sheffield Logo

    Redbrik - Sheffield

    837 Ecclesall Road, Sheffield, S11 8TH
    Average 4.7/5 Stars

    (219 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    7th Oct 2026 (25 days ago)
    I don’t usually write reviews but felt i must after the amazing service i have had from Redbrik in Crystal Peaks.<br><br>From the initial valuation through to the negotiations and completion all members of staff i have dealt with have been extremely professional and friendly.<br><br>Special mention to Louise who helped steady my nerves with her excellent communication in the latter stages.<br><br>I would throughly recommend this company.<br><br>Thank you for all you did... Read more
  16. Saxton Mee - Banner Cross Logo

    Saxton Mee - Banner Cross

    949-951 Ecclesall Road, Heeley, Sheffield, S11 8TN
    Average 4.8/5 Stars

    (249 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    24th Oct 2026 (8 days ago)
    We had such a fantastic experience with Saxton mee Louise and all the team were great and so helpful! We bought and sold with Saxton mee and would definitely recommend them!... Read more
  17. United Homes - Oughtibridge Logo

    United Homes - Oughtibridge

    17b Langsett Road South, Oughtibridge, S35 0GY
    Average 4.8/5 Stars

    (60 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    5th Sep 2026 (8 weeks ago)
    ?????<br><br>United Homes provided an excellent experience from start to finish. The team was professional, friendly, and responsive, with clear communication throughout. Everything was handled efficiently and smoothly, making the process straightforward and stress-free. I would happily recommend United Homes for their reliable and professional service.... Read more
  18. Haybrook - Chapeltown Logo

    Haybrook - Chapeltown

    4 Loundside, Sheffield, S35 2UP
    Average 4.8/5 Stars

    (230 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    14th Oct 2026 (18 days ago)
    Really pleased with the service I received from Haybrook throughout the sale of my property.<br><br>Emily was fantastic at the beginning of the process, getting everything set up, taking the photos and getting the property listed. She made the whole process of getting started really straightforward.<br><br>Karen was equally brilliant throughout the sale, keeping me updated, answering any questions and helping keep things moving along.<br><br>There were a few challenges along the way, but the team were always friendly, professional and helpful.<br><br>A big thank you to Emily, Karen and the rest of the team for all their help. I would happily recommend Haybrook to anyone looking to sell their property!... Read more
  19. Beecroft Estates - Barnsley Logo

    Beecroft Estates - Barnsley

    6-8 Park Street Wombwell, Barnsley, S73 0DJ
    Average 4.3/5 Stars

    (386 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    26th Oct 2026 (6 days ago)
    The lovely Sarah Pink was very helpful and supportive throughout our sale, great communication and advice. Wouldn’t hesitate to use Beecroft estates in the future.... Read more
  20. Bell & Co Estates - Kiveton Park Logo

    Bell & Co Estates - Kiveton Park

    79 Wales Road, Kiveton Park, Sheffield, S26 6RA
    Average 4.9/5 Stars

    (187 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    26th Oct 2026 (6 days ago)
    Exceptional service - patient, professional and personal too. Thank you so much. Highly recommend - the best estate agent by far.... Read more
  21. RedRoots Property Logo

    RedRoots Property

    Office 14 Rear Walled Garden, Nostell Business Estate, Wakefield, WF4 1AB
    Average 4.9/5 Stars

    (287 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    15th Oct 2026 (17 days ago)
    Good communication throughout... Read more
  22. Mallinson and Co - Penistone Logo

    Mallinson and Co - Penistone

    Suite 2, Penistone 1, St. Marys Street,Penistone, S36 6DT
    Average 4.8/5 Stars

    (171 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    19th Oct 2026 (13 days ago)
    Found a property through this agent and they were very helpful with great communication, Mike who showed us around a couple of properties was very informative with no pushy sales techniques, looking forward to moving into our new found house!... Read more
  23. JPM Estate Agents Logo

    JPM Estate Agents

    192 Green Road, Penistone, Sheffield, S36 6BG
    Average 5.0/5 Stars

    (82 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    25th Sep 2026 (5 weeks ago)
    Really helpful and quick responses. Very happy with the service provided by the team at JPM Estate Agents. Would recommend.... Read more
  24. Let Property Sales Logo

    Let Property Sales

    10 Victoria Circus, Glasgow, G12 9JY
    Average 4.6/5 Stars

    (416 reviews)

    Average 1/5 Stars
    13th Oct 2026 (19 days ago)
    Rude They changed my property price daily without my permission. They lower price to less than what i pay for it, Then they put the price 10 times higher than what I pay for it. This is bulling tactic... Read more
  25. Hughes Family Estate Agents - Sheffield Logo

    Hughes Family Estate Agents - Sheffield

    64 High Street, Ecclesfield, Sheffield, S35 9XD
    Average 4.9/5 Stars

    (83 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    13th Oct 2026 (19 days ago)
    ?????<br><br>Where do we even begin!<br><br>My partner and I recently sold our property through Hughes, and what a rollercoaster of a journey it's been! Through absolutely no fault of Hughes, our experience of buying and selling has certainly had its fair share of ups and downs.<br><br>It all started when we found our first potential home, only to have our offer rejected. The same thing happened with the second property, but thankfully, it was third time lucky!<br><br>Throughout this process, Lewis was incredibly patient, supportive and reassuring, always reminding us that the right property would come along for us and our family. And he was right!<br><br>Fast forward to the day before completion, and what should have been an exciting time turned into our worst nightmare when our buyers pulled out. Rachel worked tirelessly to get everything back on track, going above and beyond to help save our move. I genuinely cannot thank her enough for her determination, hard work and support during what was an incredibly stressful time.<br><br>Even on completion day, the challenges weren't quite over! The property we were purchasing hadn't been fully cleared, with numerous belongings still left behind. Danielle stepped in and communicated with our buyers, explaining the situation and why we hadn't been able to completely empty our own property.<br><br>What really stood out to us was that, whenever another problem arose, there was always someone at Hughes willing to help, reassure us and find a solution.<br><br>I'd like to say a massive personal thank you to Lewis, Rachel, Danielle and the entire Hughes team. You've all played a part in helping our family move into what we hope will be our dream home.<br><br>Buying and selling a house can be stressful at the best of times, but having the right people in your corner makes all the difference.<br><br>We genuinely couldn't have done it without you, and we'll always be grateful.<br><br>Thank you all so much! We wouldn't hesitate to recommend Hughes to anyone looking to buy or sell their home.... Read more
1
2
...
4

Agents in this area will typically be able to sell your house in S1, S2, S3, S32, S33, S36, S4 and S5.

Choosing the right estate agent in S35 matters more than most sellers realise. With 78 agents currently active across the area, performance varies considerably - some agents keep price changes to a minimum while others regularly make larger reductions. GetAgent pulls together verified sales data for every agent listed here so you can compare them on what actually counts: how quickly they sell, how much they typically reduce asking prices by, and what previous sellers say about working with them.

FAQs

Explore agents near S35

Are you thinking of selling?

Our friendly team of experts are here to guide you through the process of selling your property. Give us a ring for some free advice on how to choose the right agent for you.
  • 020 3608 6556
  • Our lines are closed
Excellent
9k+ reviews onTrustpilot

Compare all Estate Agents in S35

Compare agent performance and fees, and find the best one to sell your home.
  • Data-driven recommendations
  • No obligation
  • Fast & easy

Compare all Estate Agents in S35

Compare agent performance and fees, and find the best one to sell your home.
  • Data-driven recommendations
  • No obligation
  • Fast & easy

Get a property valuation

Get your FREE, personalised valuation report now!

  • Historical price changes and trends
  • Area demand analysis
  • List of best performing local agents
Property Value Report

Related posts

Estate agent leads a family around a potential new home.
Estate agent leads a family around a potential new home.

Estate Agents

What do estate agents do?

For each home sale there are several steps estate agents have to follow, and a minefield of legal requirements they have to comply with.…

Read more

The Estate Agent comparison site
GetAgent LinkedIn iconGetAgent Facebook iconGetAgent X icon

Get in touch

020 3608 6556

Our lines are closed


We are a company registered in England & Wales, company number 09428979.

Copyright © 2026 GetAgent Limited